The Cellar

The Cellar (http://cellar.org/index.php)
-   Technology (http://cellar.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Printer Schemes (http://cellar.org/showthread.php?t=29182)

Perry Winkle 07-04-2013 09:11 AM

Printer Schemes
 
There is a printer company (and probably others?) now selling printers that you have to pay a monthly fee based on how much you print. They detect when you are low on ink and send you new cartridges.

This is super offensive to me.

First, ink prices were (are) extortionate and people worked around this by refilling cartridges or buying off-brand cartridges. This is a perfect example of the market smoothing out pricing problems.

Second, printer companies compromised the quality of the hardware and partially subsidized the cost of the printers with the cost of ink. Hooking people with virtually free (shitty) printers, thinking they could make it up on their brand of ink.

Instead of recapturing some of that value by obvious conventional means*, they are trying to do an end run that basically makes your printer their's for life.

* Lowering the price of ink and improving the quality of printers and charging for them appropriately. -- Sure, they've trained consumers that printers should be cheap, if not free, but I have little sympathy for their short-sightedness.

Lamplighter 07-04-2013 09:18 AM

Agreed.

I read this morning that Photoshop will be now "rented out" at essentially $1/day or $240/yr

tw 07-04-2013 10:05 AM

Break open a printer cartridge. Notice how little of the 'sponge' actually contains ink.

Clodfobble 07-04-2013 04:17 PM

(Only because now most of it will be on your shirt...)

ZenGum 07-04-2013 07:18 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Printer ink and toner are outrageously overpriced. Where's that graphic that's going around, comparing it to water, oil, human blood, and heroin? Hang on ...


ETA here ya go. I was wrong about the heroin.

Attachment 44596

Lamplighter 07-04-2013 08:11 PM

There was also a "shelf life" scam happening too.

HP printers give an Alert message when the cartridge is "out of date"
(I think it is 1 year, but I'm not sure.)
Anyhow, it is from the date of manufacture, not the date of your purchase.

Go figure....

Flint 07-05-2013 03:55 PM

At a glance, the OP appears to be how many businesses pay for printer/copier/multi-funtion units--that is, lease the equipment, pay a monthly fee per the actual use of the machine and for toner, parts, service. That's toner, not ink. Laser units are more expensive up front and less expensive to keep running, regardless of purchase model. Ink printers I refer to as an 'easy-bake oven' because that is about how robust and practical they are.

Perry Winkle 07-05-2013 04:39 PM

Yeah, I'm familiar with that business model for business printers. These are low-end printers I'm talking about. The levels of subscription are like 50, 100 and 300 pages per month.

mbpark 07-05-2013 05:51 PM

Translation: HP is covering their losses on hardware and consulting with ink. They did it before to offset low margins. Now this makes it even worse.

JamesB 07-06-2013 09:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flint (Post 869439)
At a glance, the OP appears to be how many businesses pay for printer/copier/multi-funtion units--that is, lease the equipment, pay a monthly fee per the actual use of the machine and for toner, parts, service. That's toner, not ink. Laser units are more expensive up front and less expensive to keep running, regardless of purchase model. Ink printers I refer to as an 'easy-bake oven' because that is about how robust and practical they are.

I remember the good old days before the ink jet manufacturers started to supply printers with low fill "starter" ink jet cartridges. In those days it was cheaper to buy a new base level Lexmark printer than buy a set of replacement inks for your already owned Lexmark printer. No, they didn't profiteer from the ink sales.

I switched to LASER printers for my black and white home printing bout 15 years ago (one Epson that died after a lightning strike hit the power lines, a used HP4+ that cost me $75 and was still going strong when I gave it away in 2008, and a Dell 1720dn), and really haven't looked back.

Just before Christmas, we needed to do a run to Staples to buy new ink cartridges for our home inkjet printers to print our Christmas cards, and came home with a Brother MFC-9125CN Color Laser Fax/Scan/Printer instead.

Even with the short fill "starter" toner cartridges that came with the printer, with the printer on special at $250+tax, the 1000 page rating for each of the four "starter cartridges" (about 1/2 to 2/3 of normal cartridge capacity) indicated that the entire printer was going to cost less than just the cost of ink cartridges that our aging and more and more unreliable ink-jet printers would need to achieve the same number of pages. It was a no brainer. We're still running on the "starter cartridges", with the black indicating it is low and we should think about replacing it soon. I have a new 2200 page black cartridge ready to go in.

As for the per page costing of printers, where I used to work, over a decade ago, our office copier was on a 1c/page maintenance contract which covered all repairs and consumables except paper. We'd get regular phone calls asking for the counter number. With paper costing about 1c/page, we had a simple formula for costing print runs.

When the copier counter hit 1/2 million pages, then the price/page went up to about 2c/page ... to reduce our copying costs back to 1c/page we'd need to lease/buy a new copier. At 1 million pages, we were given the option of paying for all maintenance and consumables or buying a new copier.

Flint 07-06-2013 12:02 PM

I use a huge, boxy Dell business class b & w laser printer at home, stock it with after-market (shitty) replacement toners for $50 a pop, and just deal with the poor print quality inherent with cheap toner cartridges. After the initial purchase of the machine, I pay so little for toner I could do it on accumulated pocket change.

I'll be printing 'draft quality' for the price of paper, essentially, for years to come.

MetalHead 10-03-2020 11:44 AM

Yeah... HP LaserJet user here... Same thing with their color laser printers. Funny enough, their design is setup in such a way that once the cartridge sends an empty signal, even refilling it (drill a small hole in the plastic cartridge and refill with toner) still signal as empty. That's designed to screw you.

And the initial cartridges are the same size and indicate the same model number as their replacements but are only half-filled (as indicated in their user manual). That's also designed to screw you.

Undertoad 10-03-2020 11:49 AM

^ Text is identical to reddit post from a year ago; IP address from Pakistan; spam incoming

Gravdigr 10-03-2020 02:24 PM

The BanHammer stirs from its slumber...unhappily.

monster 10-03-2020 04:53 PM

say it isn't so...... not after that intriguing post about scarves and outfits for when you feel bloated which I'm sure wasn't plagiarized from anywhere.....

sexobon 10-03-2020 05:02 PM

That was a reddit post from 4 years ago.

We can conclude that MetalHead has a TARDIS, probably stolen, not smart enough to be a time lord.

MetalHead 10-03-2020 10:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Undertoad (Post 1058988)
^ Text is identical to reddit post from a year ago; IP address from Pakistan; spam incoming

I am really very sorry about this, I ma very new to this forum and I can't check the date, my intention was just to initiate with the help of someone's else. I have to check and search a relevant issue on the Google and answered here. But next time I will be very careful about this.

Undertoad 10-03-2020 11:11 PM

Hey, if you're not a spammer we are happy for the visit.

sexobon 10-04-2020 12:21 AM

I suppose we have to consider that this is the way some will opt to communicate here. This method may be being made more mainstream by exposure to Artificial Intelligence. AI assistant interfaces like Amazon Echo are certainly available in Lahore, Pakistan and Alexa draws upon internet sources to answer questions (reply) often even specifying the source. People who want to communicate in secondary languages always could similarly use search engines to find phrases in those languages for use as forum replies. Nowadays; however, they may be better received by others already adjusted to the methodology via their own AI assistants.

Just sayin' it's within the realm of possibility.

xoxoxoBruce 10-04-2020 01:46 AM

1 Attachment(s)
My Canon ip4500 finally quit, wouldn't light up or stir at all. I checked the cord and the main switch but they were cool.
No obvious damage to the circuit boards. Now I've got maybe 30 of the PGI-5 and CLI-8 ink cartridges so I'll buy another one of the same.
Silly me, they're long gone but I figured I could buy son-of-printer or grandson. Nope, great grandson did LSD and great great great grandson is totally weird, wants nothing to do with my cartridges.

I do a search on the net and ebay has two, a NOS and a used, both priced around $500.
But I also saw power supplies, all used but working(would they lie to me, their oldest and dearest friend), the three were in China, Czechoslovakia, and Canada.
I picked Canada being a North American chauvinist pig. It took 2 weeks and didn't work. I went back to ebay and only the NOS was left and the price was $1000.
Nope, no way, bye bye.

So I start reading reviews and getting more confused, bothered, and bewildered. Laser doesn't have the color quality for photos, got to be inkjet.
I ended up with a Canon TS9120, cheap and very good reviews. Has a scanner, but I already have a big flatbed. I make my own greeting card and the old scanner I could do 10 at a time standing up in the rear slot on top. This one I can only print one at a time. It's wireless capable, I use a wire. It does print labels, not for but on CDs. Of course right after I bought it they discontinued that model and cut the price in half but I've learned to expect that.

What I was not expecting was this pop-up...

Attachment 71651

It started when the magenta was at about the level the yellow is now.
The old one just said ink is low and I'd have to lift the lid to see which light was flashing then walk waaaaayyyyy into the front bedroom, I swear it's 20 ft if it's an inch, plus all the way back, uphill both ways, to replace it.
I'm going to have to look into killing this "feature". :eyebrow:

MetalHead 10-04-2020 07:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Undertoad (Post 1059011)
Hey, if you're not a spammer we are happy for the visit.

Thanks for your cooperation and understanding

Gravdigr 10-05-2020 09:06 PM

The Banhammer grumbles in a grouchy manner about being woken for nothing.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:42 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.