Illegal aliens a Social Security boon
 

http://www.wpherald.com/storyview.ph...5-095501-6756r

By UNITED PRESS INTERNATIONAL
Published April 5, 2005

STOCKTON, California -- Illegal aliens contribute $7 billion a year to U.S. Social Security coffers, and, given their immigrations status, are unlikely to ever collect benefits.

With debates in Congress over immigration and Social Security, the cross between the two issues has taken an interesting turn. There are an estimated 7 million illegal immigrants in the United States and they pay some $7 billion a year into the Social Security system, The New York Times reported.

The newspaper said the Social Security Administration, beginning in the 1980s, noticed a large number of W-2 reports with incorrect or faked Social Security numbers. Over the 1990s some $189 billion worth of wages were records by the SSA, the Times said.

The time frame coincides with the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act, which set penalties for people who knowingly hire illegal aliens. A brisk business in fake identification and SSNs quickly grew, provided legal cover for the employers and, so far, a windfall for the SSA.

An SSA official told the Times the administration estimated 3/4 of illegal immigrants -- estimated by the Census Bureau at 3.8 million households -- pay payroll taxes. Those immigrants are not eligible to receive Social Security benefits.

So let's see... 3/4 of the estimated 7 million illegal immigrants is 5,250,000.

$7 billion divided by 5,250,000 is $1333.33 per person per year.

In return for which they get free healthcare, schooling for their children, meals for their children at school (since they most likely qualify for free lunch programs), pay no property taxes (since they almost certainly rent), and live in a house three times the size of what they could afford in Mexico?

But they won't ever see a Social Security payment, just like I won't?

Boo fucking hoo.

Not a big issue but ... renters pay property taxes. It's part of the rent. Renters also pay water bills, and all the other stuff homeowners do ... we just don't see the individual tab, and can't bitch about it in quite the same way homeowners do.

you forgot to mention the tax money that is spent on building shaded areas for them to stand under while waiting for someone to hire them. oh, there's also the costs associated when the police stumble across 50-200 waiting in a drop house until they are released to look for work.

well, let's not forget about the expense we are paying for the thousands in our prison system, too.

The Minutemen seem to be working out, at least from the reports I've heard on the radio thus far.

yeah, what i've read is pretty ok. but the liberals are calling them racist rednecks and the republicans are calling them stupid rednecks...

all of talk radio land has fallen in step with Bush's immigration reform BS, so they are trying to get the average conservative to turn against "vigilantes like the minutmen".

one of the local reporters that is covering said they helped the border patrol find 172 illegals last night alone. they also identified a place where the drug runners are bringing in some pretty large quantities.

Yeah, a friend of mine was going into Mexico for Spring Break, and she was told by border guards that they had just caught the number one drug trafficker, and all the little guys were going nuts trying to get his business in his absence, so certain cities were in total chaos right now and should be avoided.

Oh! OH! ANNNND...

Let's not forget that they don't pay for car insurance.

Around $100 a month = $1200 a year, almost cancels out their SS loss. And MY rates rise when they hit me, which happens because they learned to drive in Mexico, where--I shit you not--their government has had to install speed bumps on the goddamned highways.


Sorry. I'll return to normal breathing shortly.

I've been listening to this whole minutemen thing unfold on the radio.. as I've said before I've known some Illegals in the past, and in thier cases, I had no problem with what they were doing, moved up here and worked their asses off for 3 years, saved as much as they could and then went back home (presumably much wealthier than they were when they left), as to the ones who move up here and just live? the main problem I have with them is that they are taking up huge numbers of jobs in the industry in which I work. In Kansas City there are now kitchens with entirely illegal staffs (except the management of course) which is driving the wages and benefits (which are rare enough) down and suffice to say that sucks.

but then again.. 99% of us are illegal immigrants as well..
then again... we did conquer this nation, and as much as I kinda feel bad about that, in all of history the natives here got out of being invaded pretty well off.

*ducking*

i'm not too sure about that.
how do you figure?

immigrants? yes. illegal immigrants? no.

Speak for yourself :D I had an uncle who started out in Austria, was turned back from the US, so he jumped ship in Nicaragua and made his way up to Wisconsin to join his brothers, quite illegally, over a period of several years. (Well, yeah, it was 80 years ago)

Don't get me wrong, I'm very nervous about the illegal immigrant problems right now as much as the rest of you, but I have to admit that if it were ME on the other side of whatever barrier had been erected between my family and security and opportunity, I'd be doing everything they have done, and more.

........Bitchbitchbitchbitchbitch coloured people are taking my job/tax/money/home/sponging off the system...I bet you'd all change your tune if you saw what happened if they all left. If you want to get into the fiscal nittygritty about how badly done by you are I'd advise a quick primer on deflationary pressure.

We hate the shit out of white illegals too. Goddamn Canadians.

You can't trust anybody whose head flaps like that when they talk.

I had an argument with a man in my local last night. I interrupted a conversation that sounded interesting and after hearing him pose the question, 'Who owns this world? Us or the government?' I tried to explain that the government is made up of people too, and they are not that different from anyone in this pub. He got slightly agitated at this and said did I not think his opinion was important then? I said yes, but no more important than anyone elses, and how would poor Tony Blair deal with 60 million people turning up at his doorstep all insisting that their opinion was the right one? He then got ever so slightly more agitated and said 'Look lady, you've got a lot to learn mumble mumble mumble' and left the building.

I forget the point of telling you this but it is something along the lines of not being able to change the system to your benefit, and stop thinking you're right. Oh and stop worrying about what everyone else is doing and enjoy your own life, which naturally never causes anyone harm in sweat shops, financial deficit or sheer annoyance.