Maybe you are attracted subconsiously to the broken ones?
No insult taken -- I've considered this. I've listened to enough of
Love Lines in my time to know that that is often how it works.
If that is the case, I have to break out of it. I know I can't take it, anymore. I have, in fact, dated non-broken girls and those relationships usually ended because they had a habit I couldn't stand and they refused to give up or lighten up (mostly smoking).
I can't tolerate that smell, much less a kiss from one. Eech.