View Single Post
Old 10-13-2006, 12:35 PM   #118
Undertoad
Radical Centrist
 
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Cottage of Prussia
Posts: 31,423
Spexx,

I'm not sure I take the right lesson of your morality tale.

Through the course of a few short sentences your friend's brother became a violent felon. The outcome of getting shot by his own gun is probably one of the best possible. At least he did not kill or seriously hurt anyone else, and society didn't have to work too hard or pay too much to clean up his mess.

In order for this tale to be anti-gun, we have to have more concern for this guy's life and safety than he did.

We have to notice that the innocent person being attacked was probably unarmed.

We have to notice that the attacker had time and room to choose any approach, including calling the cops if he felt there was a threat; and so, he would have been a violent homophobic killer with a knife, if that were the favored method of violent homophobic killers everywhere.

We have to not put his face on the statistics that say you might be shot by your own gun. Sure, if you are a violent homophobic felon bringing home TVs from bars, you might well get shot by your own gun. If you don't behave like that, your chances become miniscule.

Meanwhile, if I have to be around violent homophobic felons, I will want to have a gun.

It's harsh because you have some connection to this person, but this person was too stupid to live free, and was inches away from landing on death row no matter what the outcome of that night.
Undertoad is offline   Reply With Quote