The mission is education, but job-training is just one of the hidden expectations.
So, at times,
grades become the ultimate goal for some students and/or parents.
NY Times - 12/25/10
A Quest to Explain What Grades Really Mean
Quote:
It could be a Zen koan: if everybody in the class gets an A, what does an A mean ?
|
A corollary is: if everybody in the class gets an C, what does an C mean ?
Quote:
With college grades creeping ever higher,
a few universities have taken direct action against grade inflation.
Most notably, Princeton adopted guidelines in 2004 providing that
no more than 35 percent of undergraduate grades should be A’s,
a policy that remains controversial on campus.
Others have taken a less direct approach,
leaving instructors free to award whatever grades they like
but expanding their transcripts to include information
giving graduate schools and employers a fuller picture
of what the grades mean.
<snip>
Studies of grade inflation have found that private universities generally give higher grades than public ones,
and that humanities courses award higher grades than science and math classes.
|
The article describes several schools that include a calculated "median grade" in the transcript.
Quote:
“It’s complicated, it’s controversial, and it runs into campus political opposition
from all sorts of directions you might not anticipate,” Mr. Nassirian said,
adding that transcripts with too much extra information can become unwieldy.
|
But the "median" seems cumbersome and hides information,
when it's the "cumulative percentile" or "rank" that is more informative.
Median: half of the grades are higher, half are lower
Rank: relative position within all grades of the class/school.
The advantage of a "cumulative percentile" is that it shows the distribution of grades in the group,
so it's immediately evident when there are clusters of grades: high, low, or in the middle