Most Perfect Rock Song Ever?

11-08-2001, 05:20 PM

I've been thinking lately. I think I know the most perfect rock song ever. We're not talking in terms of popularity. Just in terms of being a great great song. Builds up well, ends well.

What do you think is the most perfect rock song ever?

My vote: Pearl Jam - Corduroy

Gotta give real high vote to Soundgarden - Overfloater though. Damn fine rock song as well. But I think Pearl Jam edges it out by a bit.

Now it's your turn to tell

Hubris Boy · 11-08-2001, 05:49 PM

Oh, hell... that's easy:

John Hiatt- Perfectly Good Guitar

Glad I could clear that up for you!

(Close 2nd: Lloyd Cole & The Commotions- My Bag)

Undertoad · 11-08-2001, 06:30 PM

Thinks to himself: Someone else has heard LC & t C's 3rd album. There is still hope in the world.

The question is really one of what you mean by "rock". How much "roll" has to be removed; does Elvis count? How much pop has to be removed; do the Beatles count? What year did it begin, and what year did it die, if it is dead?

Xugumad · 11-08-2001, 07:42 PM

Depends. Kitschy cliched music can still rock hard, as long as you don't snort in pseudo-postmodernistic irony at everything that's not independent, 'authentic' music.

Yes, I'm looking at *you*.

Covers:

Gun - "Word Up" (Cameo cover)
The Lemonheads - "Mrs. Robinson" (Simon & Garfunkel cover)
Metallica - "Astronomy" (Blue Öyster Cult cover)

Originals:

The Pixies - "Debaser"
Therapy - "Screamager"
Pearl Jam - "Yellow Ledbetter"
Oasis - "Fucking in the Bushes"
Alice Cooper - "Feed my Frankenstein"
Iron Maiden - "Fear of the Dark"

Rock. No doubt about it. Go to www.audiogalaxy.com, download the satellite, set it up, download the songs, and listen. Then go and buy the albums.

X.

elSicomoro · 11-08-2001, 10:19 PM

I don't know if there is a "perfect" rock song, but there are some damned fine rock songs out there...

Led Zeppelin--"Kashmir"
Soundgarden--"Black Hole Sun"
Anthrax--"This Is Not an Exit"
Pearl Jam--"Faithfull"

jet_silver · 11-08-2001, 11:03 PM

X - Los Angeles is a song I'd -have- to have on the proverbial desert island.

The Raybeats - Holiday Inn Spain is the quintessence of surf music IMO, but since it doesn't have lyrics it might not qualify as a 'song'.

Best unknown (any Canadians around here?) Doug and the Slugs - Too Bad.

Undertoad · 11-09-2001, 04:07 PM

Jet, your fellow Canuck Norm MacDonald educated the US to Doug and the Slugs "Too Bad", when he used it as the theme to his TV show.

I liked it better than the Barenaked Ladies, but when it comes to quirky rock and the Great White North, I prefer Odds. Unfortunately Odds released their strongest album ever and then promptly broke up. I think I'm one of about 10,000 people in the US who cared.

As to the previous question, nobody wanted to take on my followup questions and so I have had to answer them for myself.

The Most Perfect Rock Song Ever has to be simple. It has to be straight-forward, honest, and come from the gut (as opposed to the brain). But most importantly, it has to speak of the heartbreak of a member of the appropriate sex who has left prematurely.

And so, the Most Perfect Rock Song Ever is the dB's "Amplifier".

Danny went home and killed himself last night
She'd taken everything
She'd taken everything
She took his car
She took his bike
She took everything
She thought he liked
And what she couldn't take, she found a way to break
But she left his amplifier

11-09-2001, 04:24 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Undertoad
As to the previous question, nobody wanted to take on my followup questions and so I have had to answer them for myself.

The Most Perfect Rock Song Ever has to be simple. It has to be straight-forward, honest, and come from the gut (as opposed to the brain). But most importantly, it has to speak of the heartbreak of a member of the appropriate sex who has left prematurely.

Well... from my choice...

the waiting drove me mad... you're finally here and i'm a mess .... can't buy what i want because it's free... can't buy what i want because it's free... can't be what you want because i'm...

lost love... you personally now know how it relates to me and an ordeal i went through last year... but it's simple, it works... look up the lyrics some time if you're not already intimately familiar with the song... great great song...

elSicomoro · 11-09-2001, 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Undertoad
I liked it better than the Barenaked Ladies, but when it comes to quirky rock and the Great White North, I prefer Odds. Unfortunately Odds released their strongest album ever and then promptly broke up. I think I'm one of about 10,000 people in the US who cared.

Didn't Odds have the song about the heterosexual man? Around 1993? I used to dig that song.

My favorite Canadian band is Skinny Puppy, although they're not quite rock, but ARE quirky.

Undertoad · 11-09-2001, 11:10 PM

Yep, that's right, "Heterosexual Man".

And of course for Canuck bands, there's always Rush. Who may go on forever, gawblessum.

markmarion · 11-10-2001, 11:58 AM

The definitive and seminal true 'Rock' song has to be

( and I pause and take my pulse here, because it seems this band are unheard of in the US - which I find staggering)

"The Ace of Spades"
by Motorhead

closely followed by

"For Those About to Rock"
by AC/DC

Or indeed, anything by AC/DC. Anything by Motorhead for that matter!

MM

elSicomoro · 11-10-2001, 09:06 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by markmarion
The definitive and seminal true 'Rock' song has to be

( and I pause and take my pulse here, because it seems this band are unheard of in the US - which I find staggering)

"The Ace of Spades"
by Motorhead

LEMMY!!! Actually, that's not true at all Mark. Motorhead are generally well-regarded in the States, particularly in the hard rock/heavy metal arena...and have actually sold quite a few records.

Scopulus Argentarius · 11-10-2001, 09:22 PM

Rush

Rush

Rush

& 'Yes' and sometime the 'New' Yes or 'Yeah' as I call 'em.

Which reminds me of this time I picked up this attractive looking chick in a noisy-drunky-hole-in-the-wall-bar-that-I-frequented. Before the night had expired, I found that she had the same tastes : We both liked Rush...We both liked Yes...and ..er.. We both liked Chicks.... Oh well..

Sort of funny a decade or so after the fact.

P.S. We were pals for some time...

elSicomoro · 11-10-2001, 09:57 PM

Ooooh! Rush! Man, I went on a Rush kick during 1992 and 1993 (which was ironic, given that grunge was in full-bloom and I was digging the hell out of that). They still kick ass...hopefully they'll be able to pull back together and make a new album soon. Apparently, Geddy is releasing (or has already released) a solo CD, which I'd be curious to hear. I didn't dig Alex Lifeson's project (Victor) too much, although I own the CD.

Hubris Boy · 11-10-2001, 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by sycamore Apparently, Geddy is releasing (or has already released) a solo CD

Hello Kitty is horrified by the prospect of a Geddy Lee solo album. Hello Kitty used to like Rush very much, and still listens to 2112 sometimes, when nobody else is around...

But the thought of Geddy Lee adenoidaling away, seven octaves above her pain threshold without the modifying influence of Neal Peart on the drums, is more than Hello Kitty can bear.

11-08-2001, 05:20 PM	#1
dave Guest Posts: n/a	Most Perfect Rock Song Ever? I've been thinking lately. I think I know the most perfect rock song ever. We're not talking in terms of popularity. Just in terms of being a great great song. Builds up well, ends well. What do you think is the most perfect rock song ever? My vote: Pearl Jam - Corduroy Gotta give real high vote to Soundgarden - Overfloater though. Damn fine rock song as well. But I think Pearl Jam edges it out by a bit. Now it's your turn to tell

11-08-2001, 06:30 PM	#3
Undertoad Radical Centrist Join Date: Jan 2001 Location: Cottage of Prussia Posts: 31,423	Thinks to himself: <i>Someone else has heard LC & t C's 3rd album. There is still hope in the world.</i> The question is really one of what you mean by "rock". How much "roll" has to be removed; does Elvis count? How much pop has to be removed; do the Beatles count? What year did it begin, and what year did it die, if it is dead?

11-08-2001, 07:42 PM	#4
Xugumad Punisher of Good Deeds Join Date: Apr 2001 Posts: 183	Depends. Kitschy cliched music can still rock hard, as long as you don't snort in pseudo-postmodernistic irony at everything that's not independent, 'authentic' music. Yes, I'm looking at you. Covers: Gun - "Word Up" (Cameo cover) The Lemonheads - "Mrs. Robinson" (Simon & Garfunkel cover) Metallica - "Astronomy" (Blue Öyster Cult cover) Originals: The Pixies - "Debaser" Therapy - "Screamager" Pearl Jam - "Yellow Ledbetter" Oasis - "Fucking in the Bushes" Alice Cooper - "Feed my Frankenstein" Iron Maiden - "Fear of the Dark" Rock. No doubt about it. Go to www.audiogalaxy.com, download the satellite, set it up, download the songs, and listen. Then go and buy the albums. X. Last edited by Xugumad; 11-09-2001 at 09:20 AM.

11-08-2001, 10:19 PM	#5
elSicomoro Person who doesn't update the user title Join Date: Jan 2001 Posts: 12,486	Hmmm... I don't know if there is a "perfect" rock song, but there are some damned fine rock songs out there... Led Zeppelin--"Kashmir" Soundgarden--"Black Hole Sun" Anthrax--"This Is Not an Exit" Pearl Jam--"Faithfull"

11-08-2001, 11:03 PM	#6
jet_silver wazmo medio Join Date: Jun 2001 Location: San Narciso, CA Posts: 53	X - Los Angeles is a song I'd -have- to have on the proverbial desert island. The Raybeats - Holiday Inn Spain is the quintessence of surf music IMO, but since it doesn't have lyrics it might not qualify as a 'song'. Best unknown (any Canadians around here?) Doug and the Slugs - Too Bad. __________________ "De lood van die Goevernement sal nou op julle smelt." -Thomas Pynchon

11-08-2001, 05:49 PM	#2
Hubris Boy Keymaster of Gozer Join Date: Jul 2001 Location: Patapsco Drainage Basin Posts: 471	Oh, hell... that's easy: John Hiatt- Perfectly Good Guitar Glad I could clear that up for you! (Close 2nd: Lloyd Cole & The Commotions- My Bag)

11-09-2001, 04:07 PM	#7
Undertoad Radical Centrist Join Date: Jan 2001 Location: Cottage of Prussia Posts: 31,423	Jet, your fellow Canuck Norm MacDonald educated the US to Doug and the Slugs "Too Bad", when he used it as the theme to his TV show. I liked it better than the Barenaked Ladies, but when it comes to quirky rock and the Great White North, I prefer Odds. Unfortunately Odds released their strongest album ever and then promptly broke up. I think I'm one of about 10,000 people in the US who cared. As to the previous question, nobody wanted to take on my followup questions and so I have had to answer them for myself. The Most Perfect Rock Song Ever has to be simple. It has to be straight-forward, honest, and come from the gut (as opposed to the brain). But most importantly, it has to speak of the heartbreak of a member of the appropriate sex who has left prematurely. And so, the Most Perfect Rock Song Ever is the dB's "Amplifier". <i>Danny went home and killed himself last night She'd taken everything She'd taken everything She took his car She took his bike She took everything She thought he liked And what she couldn't take, she found a way to break But she left his amplifier </i>

11-09-2001, 11:10 PM	#10
Undertoad Radical Centrist Join Date: Jan 2001 Location: Cottage of Prussia Posts: 31,423	Yep, that's right, "Heterosexual Man". And of course for Canuck bands, there's always Rush. Who may go on forever, gawblessum.

11-10-2001, 11:58 AM	#11
markmarion Fellow-Commoner Join Date: Nov 2001 Location: London UK Posts: 10	THE most perfect Rock song The definitive and seminal true 'Rock' song has to be ( and I pause and take my pulse here, because it seems this band are unheard of in the US - which I find staggering) "The Ace of Spades" by Motorhead closely followed by "For Those About to Rock" by AC/DC Or indeed, anything by AC/DC. Anything by Motorhead for that matter! MM __________________ And furthermore (PTO)...

11-10-2001, 09:22 PM	#13
Scopulus Argentarius Your current user title is: Join Date: Oct 2001 Location: BTR Posts: 301	Rush.... Rush Rush Rush & 'Yes' and sometime the 'New' Yes or 'Yeah' as I call 'em. Which reminds me of this time I picked up this attractive looking chick in a noisy-drunky-hole-in-the-wall-bar-that-I-frequented. Before the night had expired, I found that she had the same tastes : We both liked Rush...We both liked Yes...and ..er.. We both liked Chicks.... Oh well.. Sort of funny a decade or so after the fact. P.S. We were pals for some time...

11-10-2001, 09:57 PM	#14
elSicomoro Person who doesn't update the user title Join Date: Jan 2001 Posts: 12,486	Ooooh! Rush! Man, I went on a Rush kick during 1992 and 1993 (which was ironic, given that grunge was in full-bloom and I was digging the hell out of that). They still kick ass...hopefully they'll be able to pull back together and make a new album soon. Apparently, Geddy is releasing (or has already released) a solo CD, which I'd be curious to hear. I didn't dig Alex Lifeson's project (Victor) too much, although I own the CD.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)